There is no reliable blanket answer based on an AI product label alone. A law firm should assess the particular task, material and service, record what it knows, and identify who is accountable for the decision. This is an operational assessment, not legal advice or a conclusion about privilege.
Define the task and material
Start by recording what the AI would do and what information it would receive. Drafting from public material differs from summarising a privileged advice note or searching across matter files. Note the purpose, information categories, people who need access, and any relevant client instructions or engagement terms.
Map the information path
Establish what prompts, files, outputs and logs the service processes; which providers or people may access them; how long they are retained; and what deletion and model-improvement terms apply. Check current product settings and contract terms rather than relying on a general product description. Confirm how matter permissions are applied and whether information could cross client or matter boundaries.
Compare the available evidence with the firm’s confidentiality commitments, client instructions, engagement terms and internal policies. If a material fact is unknown, record it as an open question rather than treating uncertainty as proof that the use is safe or unsafe.
Keep review and accountability visible
Specify what the system may support, what remains a human decision, and who checks outputs before they inform advice or reach a client. The reviewer should be able to inspect relevant source material, test uncertain statements, correct the output and decide not to use it.
Keep a proportionate decision record covering the task, information involved, provider evidence, applicable controls, accountable owner, review point and conditions that trigger reassessment. If the firm cannot establish a key part of the information path or review arrangement, pause that proposed use of the material while the evidence gap is addressed.
Choose a practical next step
Pattrn Data’s AI Risk & Efficiency Audit can help a firm map AI uses, information flows, owners, hand-offs, review points and controls before wider rollout or tool spend. For a focused question, an AI Clarity Consultation can help frame a bounded next step. Neither replaces qualified legal advice on a specific matter.
Source and scope
This article was informed by the Law Society Journal discussion of client generative-AI use and privilege risk. That discussion includes examples from multiple jurisdictions and is not a statement of law for every firm or matter. The checklist above is general operational guidance, not legal advice.